Decoding Shopify App Store Ranking: Why Store Closures & Sidekick are Stirring Up Debate

Hey everyone,

If you've got an app on the Shopify App Store, you know how vital visibility is. Getting your app in front of the right merchants can make or break your growth. That's why when the community starts buzzing about the fairness of the App Store ranking algorithm, my ears perk up – and yours should too!

Recently, a really insightful discussion popped up in the Shopify community forums, originally titled something like "App Store ranking: please exclude store-closure uninstalls from the app growth signal." But the conversation quickly expanded beyond just that, revealing some deeper concerns about how apps are discovered and ranked. Let's dive into what our fellow app developers and merchants are talking about.

The Unfair Penalties: Store Closures & Your App's "Growth"

The main point that sparked this whole discussion came from Abishek, Co-Founder of Logbase (you might know their popular apps like Selleasy or Pickeasy). He flagged a significant concern for established apps: the way Shopify calculates "net growth" for ranking purposes.

From what Abishek observed, and what many others silently suspect, the ranking algorithm heavily factors in your app's net growth – essentially, new installs minus uninstalls. Sounds reasonable, right? The problem, he pointed out, is that it seems to include uninstalls caused by store closures. Think about it: a merchant decides to close their Shopify store, and your app gets uninstalled automatically. This isn't because they disliked your app; their business simply ceased operations.

Abishek laid out why this is fundamentally unfair:

  • Store closure uninstalls tend to grow with your install base. The more successful your app, the more stores it's in, and naturally, the more likely some of those stores will eventually close.
  • At scale, these closures can actually outnumber new installs, making a truly well-loved and high-quality app appear to have "negative growth" in the ranking system.
  • The bitter irony? The more successful an app gets, the more it's penalized. A store closing isn't a "vote against" your app; it's just the unfortunate reality of business.

His suggestion is simple and logical: exclude store-closure uninstalls from the ranking growth signal, while still counting merchant-initiated uninstalls as a true quality indicator. This would give a much clearer picture of an app's actual performance and value.

Sidekick's Shadow: Cannibalizing App Discovery?

As the conversation unfolded, another big topic emerged: Shopify's AI assistant, Sidekick. Several community members, including Abishek himself and Olllie, noted that Sidekick seems to be "cannibalizing app store search."

What does this mean for you, the store owner or app developer? It means that Sidekick, by recommending a few top apps directly, might be inadvertently creating an unfair playing field. As BookingFat put it, the "top three apps will continue to receive a disproportionate number of installs simply because they are recommended directly by Shopify, rather than giving users an equal opportunity to discover other apps through independent recommendations or organic search." This makes it incredibly tough for newer, innovative apps to break through and gain visibility, even if they're offering fantastic solutions.

A Glimpse into Shopify's Intent: Balancing the Scales?

Interestingly, BookingFat also offered a different perspective on Shopify's overall ranking strategy. They suggested that Shopify might actually be trying to give newer, high-quality apps more visibility. The idea is to prevent long-established apps with huge install bases but perhaps slower recent growth from dominating the rankings indefinitely. While this approach has its merits in fostering innovation, it clearly has unintended consequences, like the store-closure issue and Sidekick's impact, that need to be addressed to ensure genuine fair competition.

So, You've Got Feedback? Here's How to Get Heard

This is where the community discussion really provided some actionable insights. While it's great to share your thoughts in the forums (and please keep doing so!), for issues directly related to App Store ranking algorithms, you need to use the right channel to ensure your voice reaches the relevant team at Shopify.

Lauren_Scott, a helpful community member, clarified that "Forum replies don't reach the App Store ranking team." This is a critical piece of information! Instead, she advised, this type of request has to go through Partner Support in writing. Abishek, the original poster, promptly followed this advice, confirming he raised the issue through Partner support.

If you're experiencing similar issues or have specific feedback on how the App Store ranking works, here’s a clear path to follow:

  1. Contact Shopify Partner Support: This is your direct line to the teams that can action your feedback. You'll typically find this option within your Shopify Partner Dashboard.
  2. Clearly State Your Case: Explain the issue concisely, just like Abishek did with the store-closure uninstalls. Articulate why you believe it's unfair or problematic for the ecosystem.
  3. Request Forwarding: Crucially, ask Partner Support to "pass the [specific issue, e.g., store-closure point] to the App Store ranking team." Make it explicit that this feedback needs to reach that specific internal team.
  4. Attach Your Data: This is key! Don't just make a general complaint. Include concrete data from your app – your install and uninstall numbers, especially highlighting instances where store closures have impacted your perceived "growth." Data makes your case much stronger and helps the team understand the scale of the problem.

Remember, collective feedback makes a difference. The more developers and merchants who raise these points through the correct channels with supporting data, the more likely Shopify is to review and potentially adjust its algorithms for a fairer and more transparent App Store experience. It’s all about creating a robust ecosystem where great apps can thrive, no matter their age or current ranking.

Share:

Start with the tools

Explore migration tools

See options, compare methods, and pick the path that fits your store.

Explore migration tools